Monday, April 17, 2006

Reasons why not

I hear it in a lot of songs but am noticing it more and more in everyday speech, the phrase "the reason why".

Obviously, why rhymes with a lot more things than reason does (season, teasin', pleasin' is about all you get in song lyrics these days) so I can accept the poetic licence angle but in everyday speech, the sentence "He did it without knowing the reason why." is, I'm afraid, completely unnecessary.

Can I give you a reason? Can I tell you why?

Well, I've just illustrated it: they're kind of the same thing. If you're asking someone "why?", you could just as well be asking "for what reason?". The meaning is identical. In my earlier example, it would be sufficient to leave out either option: "He did it without knowing the reason," or "He did it without knowing why,".

To use both is tautologically superfluous, yeah?

So stop using it in everyday speech. And if you're a songwriter that employs the phrase, you could really do with taking a longer look in the rhyming dictionary when you're sitting at the piano.


Thomas McAllister said...

In a freshman-level composition course at a university in America, I was taught to write "the reason that..." in certain constructions: "The reason that I went to the store was to buy milk." Of course, in this sentence the that is unnecessary clutter, and ultimately it would probably be better simply to say, "I went to the store to buy milk." I do think songwriters should take time out to consult their rhyming dictionaries: there are so many other words that end in the long "i" vowel.

AJ said...

Speaking of "what for" vs "why", it reminds me of my favourite joke:

Q: What does E.T. stand for?
A: Because he doesn't have a chair.

(Everyone ALWAYS answers "Extra Terrestrial") :)

redcap said...

"Tautologically superfluous". Very nice, grammar nazi.

Skanky Jane said...

*nods in agreement* - very nice indeed! I need this blog!

I found you through The Adelaide Index when searching for Adelaide art related blogfellows.

*grimace* I shall have to be careful when commenting here.

SJ xx

Clovergirl said...

I've just found your blog... and I love it. Well done, well done, well done.

kuku fashion australia said...

WOW!, Thanks for the nice Blog. This is really Fantastic. Enjoy online fashion shopping with us! WeĆ¢ve redefined Australian womens dress and clothes shopping with huge collections of many popular brands. Like kuku fashion australia , alma fashion , kuku , kuku dress , mad love stockist , toi et moi stockist , kuku dresses , kuku fashion , mad love fashion , toi et moi online , toi et moi jacket . Thanks for staying with us.

Donna Christensen said...

Professional Face Painting Artist serving in the Virginia Area. We are the BEST - face painter, body painter with glitter tattoo, theatrical makeup as best picasso glitter tattoo in face painter VA, face painter Hampton Roads, face painter Tidewater, face painter Norfolk, face painter Newport News. We provide services with Reasonable Prices. Thanks for staying with us.

Green earthconcept said...

HELP TO SAVE THE WORLD. Thanks for the Great Post. Green Earth Concept Malaysia is for green world. We want a Green earth for LIVE, why we need- green home, green products, green product, buy green, eco friendly products, environmental products, eco green products, environmentally friendly products. Thank you for staying with us.

Solinteg Groupe Conseil said...

Thanks for the Great Post. Groupe Conseil Solinteg can support -
office 365
cloud services
sharepoint online
exchange online
lync online
cloud services montreal
microsoft crm montreal
windows intune
and many more services and product from Microsoft Corporation. Thanks.

best wedding coordinator washington state said...

Excellent & Cool! – I should definitely say I'm impressed with your blog. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs as well as related info. The site ended up being truly simple to access. Excellent job.. Carry-on. About us..! please visit.
seattle wedding planner
tacoma wedding planner
woodinville wedding planner
tacoma event planner
woodinville event planner
number one wedding planner seattle
tacoma wedding coordinator
tacoma event coordinator
best wedding coordinator washington state
best wedding planner washington state
best wedding planner seattle
best wedding planner tacoma